2012 Ford Mustang Boss 302
...the Ford Mustang Boss 302. Oh, I know, here come the Chevy and Mopar folks telling me I'm biased because I own a bunch of Fords, but the Fords I own were all made before Clinton was in office -- some before Nixon. So that's that.
I love the Boss because it moves well, sounds good, looks good, and is enjoyable to be in, not just be seen in. It's an absolute hammer on the road, does so without the lumpy, surging weirdness of turbos and blowers, and is just this side of too wild for daily use.
If there was ever a topic that called for a quick poll, this is it!
Least favorite on the list? In one key way, the Camaro SS. I just can't get past that turret slit of a windshield and cave-like interior, and I find it fundamentally occludes your ability to know where the car is when you're pushing it. Maybe if I owned and drove one for a longer time, I'd get over it. The SS is the least rorty car on our list, though also the cheapest and the only one that is really affordable for a lot of people. I think that deserves a runner-up award.